How does withdrawal order change taxes and savings?
Maya is 66 and wants to know which accounts to draw from first. Her comparison shows why the lowest tax total is not necessarily the strongest spending plan.
Written by James Wilson · Calculated and reviewed November 16, 2026
Maya’s starting plan
| Input | Fictional assumption |
|---|---|
| Household | Single, Washington; age 66 in 2026 |
| Traditional IRA | $700,000 |
| Roth IRA | $120,000 |
| Taxable cash | $150,000 |
| Starting annual spending | $70,000, including healthcare |
| Entered Social Security | $3,200 a month at 67, in claim-year dollars |
| Comparison and ending ages | 80 and 95 |
Maya has retired. Each alternative uses the same spending, benefit timing, balances, and economic assumptions. Only the discretionary withdrawal order changes. Required minimum distributions still apply.
Compare account priorities, not just the tax bill
| Measure | Taxable Accounts First | Traditional IRA First | Tax-Bracket Managed (12%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income tax in 2026 | $0 | $6,172 | $6,172 |
| Portfolio at 80 | $531,525 | $435,655 | $422,651 |
| Portfolio at 95 | $34,191 | $0 | $0 |
| Total modeled income tax through 95 | $130,926 | $111,329 | $112,277 |
| First spending shortfall | None through 95 | Age 93 | Age 93 |
Dollar basis: Portfolio balances and the total tax row use 2026 purchasing power, rounded to whole dollars. Income tax in 2026 is that year’s amount. Portfolio balances are before any tax on remaining accounts. Income tax totals include modeled federal and state income tax, not payroll taxes.
Taxable Accounts First covers Maya’s planned spending through 95 in this path. Traditional IRA First and the 12% bracket-managed setting first fall short at 93. Although those alternatives show less total tax, that does not make them better: they also leave less money to fund later spending. The bracket target is a control to test, not an automatic improvement.
What these results assume
Every asset category earns a steady 4% nominal annual return. Inflation and assumed Social Security COLAs are 2.5% a year; investment fees are zero. These are chosen assumptions, not a forecast or a historical sequence. The projection runs from 2026 through age 95 and includes modeled income tax and required distributions. Future tax amounts may be projections.
Healthcare is included in the spending budget; premiums, Medicare IRMAA, and ACA credits are not calculated separately here. There are no pensions, brokerage capital gains, IRA basis, future deposits, or contributions. Retirement starts in January of the specified age year. Monthly Social Security uses a June benefit-start month at 67, with the first payment the following month. Benefits come from the entered estimate, not a reconstructed SSA earnings record.
Try the comparison yourself
Export your own plan first if you want a separate file backup. Download one fictional plan below and choose Plan → Import Plan in Free or Plus. Importing replaces the current browser inputs. The imported plan selects Claim at 67 with the applicable conversion choice. Review Scenario Highlights for inflation-adjusted balances at 80 and 95. Year-by-Year Details uses Future Dollars, so its later-year amounts will be larger than the purchasing-power figures above.
- Maya: Taxable Accounts First (JSON plan)
- Maya: Traditional IRA First (JSON plan)
- Maya: Tax-Bracket Managed (12%) (JSON plan)
Open the withdrawal comparison in Plus and compare Taxable Accounts First, Traditional IRA First, and the 12% bracket-managed setting. Review taxes and spending coverage together. An optimized annual policy is an additional comparison; it was not used to generate these results.
Core inputs and file import/export are available in Free. Plus adds advanced strategy controls and comparisons, account plans, and new check-ins. Save distinct alternatives through My Plans and a dated check-in before applying changes. Test candidate strategies in Risk Analysis and relevant stress tests; larger simulations cannot guarantee future outcomes.
Download assumptions, calculation versions, and unrounded case-study results.
Related reading
Explore this with your own plan
Use the free planner to establish a baseline, then compare advanced strategies in Retirement Chartplotter Plus. Plus requires active access and runs calculations in your browser. Save account plans through My Plans and create a check-in before applying a recommendation.
Open the Planner Explore Retirement Chartplotter Plus