Retirement Chartplotter

Compare retirement strategies and chart a more informed course.

Open the Planner

Which Accounts Should You Withdraw From First in Retirement?

The best withdrawal order depends on more than which account has the lowest tax bill today. Compare how each approach funds spending, uses tax brackets, and changes later withdrawals before choosing an order.

Written by James Wilson · Calculated and reviewed November 16, 2026

Start with the amount you need to spend

Social Security, pensions, and other income cover part of a retirement budget. Withdrawals supply the remaining spending need and any additional taxes. A $40,000 spending gap does not always mean a $40,000 IRA withdrawal: taking money from a taxable retirement account can create more tax that also needs funding.

Traditional IRA distributions are generally taxable except for applicable basis. Qualified Roth IRA distributions are tax-free. Selling brokerage investments can realize gains rather than making the entire sale taxable. Cash withdrawals do not themselves create income, although interest may. Those distinctions make account type and cost basis important inputs.

Three approaches to compare

Taxable Accounts First

Start with taxable cash and brokerage assets when extra money is needed. This can preserve IRA and Roth balances, but may defer taxable distributions into later years.

Traditional IRA First

Start with traditional retirement accounts. This uses taxable income capacity now and changes the balances available for later RMDs.

Tax-Bracket Managed

Use a selected federal bracket target to guide distributions. A target is a constraint to test, not a promise that filling it is beneficial.

Required distributions still apply before the discretionary order. “First” means an account priority, not automatically emptying an account.

A reproducible example, not a forecast

Alex is a fictional single Washington resident, age 63 in 2026. The starting accounts are a $600,000 Traditional IRA, a $100,000 Roth IRA, and $100,000 in taxable cash, with no IRA basis or brokerage gains. Spending is $50,000 a year unless a comparison states otherwise. Social Security is entered as $2,500 a month at 67, with no subsequent COLA. The projection ends at 95 and uses age 80 as an intermediate comparison.

Investment returns, inflation, and fees are set to zero to make the tradeoffs easier to isolate. Healthcare is included in spending, with no separately modeled premiums or ACA credits. Federal taxes and RMDs are modeled; future-year tax assumptions can be projections. This deliberately simplified cash-only example is not a typical investment plan, a probability estimate, or a recommendation.

Results were calculated 2026-11-16 using retirement-model-2026.15. Dollar values are rounded, nominal, and before any tax on remaining accounts. Zero inflation makes them equal to first-year purchasing power in this example. Downloaded files preserve the selected inputs and reviewed data; calculation fixes can still change later results.

What the comparison shows

Calculated single-path comparison
ChoiceTax in 2026Portfolio at 80First spending shortfall
Taxable Accounts First$0$300,327Age 95
Traditional IRA First$4,341$291,646Age 95
Tax-Bracket Managed$17,966$230,170Age 92

The Tax-Bracket Managed strategy uses Plus controls; the other two withdrawal orders are available in Free.

Taxable Accounts First has no income tax in the first year because cash funds spending. Traditional IRA First creates taxable distributions and must also fund their tax. The 22% bracket-managed setting produces a larger first-year tax bill and an earlier shortfall in this zero-return example. It is not the winning strategy simply because it has more controls.

All three eventually have a spending shortfall here. A higher balance at 80 does not establish that spending remains covered at 95, and a pretax balance is not the same as spendable after-tax wealth.

Download a fictional plan, then use Plan → Import Plan in the free or Plus planner. Importing replaces the current browser inputs; export your own plan first if you want to keep a separate file.

Download assumptions, calculation versions, and unrounded comparison results.

How to compare withdrawal strategies in Plus

  1. Enter account balances, IRA basis, brokerage cost basis, income, spending, and healthcare assumptions. Check the baseline projection first.
  2. Open the withdrawal comparison tool. The free planner compares Traditional IRA First and Taxable Accounts First; Plus adds tax-bracket managed and optimized annual policies.
  3. Run the comparison with the same household inputs. Review spending shortfalls, taxes, and balances at both comparison and ending ages.
  4. Review any optimized annual schedule as account priorities. Use Year-by-Year Details for actual projected distributions and taxes.
  5. Before applying a policy, test the selected strategy in Retirement Risk Analysis and relevant stress tests. Save a check-in so you can review the change later.

When the preferred order can change

Large future RMDs, Social Security taxation, IRA basis, brokerage gains, survivor filing status, healthcare subsidies, and Medicare IRMAA can change the result. A strategy that avoids IRA withdrawals now may create a less flexible tax position later. Conversely, generating income merely to fill a bracket can be costly when the plan does not benefit from doing so.

Repeat the comparison using realistic returns, inflation, spending, and healthcare. Discuss a proposed distribution strategy with a qualified tax professional before acting.

Official sources and related reading

A companion case study

How does withdrawal order change taxes and savings?

Follow a different fictional household through calculated alternatives and download the plans to reproduce the results.

Explore this with your own plan

Use the free planner to establish a baseline, then compare advanced strategies in Retirement Chartplotter Plus. Plus requires active access and runs calculations in your browser. Save account plans through My Plans and create a check-in before applying a recommendation.

Open the Planner Explore Retirement Chartplotter Plus