Retirement Chartplotter

Compare retirement strategies and chart a more informed course.

Open the Planner

How Much Should You Convert to a Roth IRA Each Year?

An annual Roth conversion amount should follow from your household’s income, spending, tax situation, and goals. A round number or a bracket ceiling is a starting point for comparison, not an answer by itself.

Written by James Wilson · Calculated and reviewed November 16, 2026

Separate a conversion from a spending withdrawal

A conversion moves money from a traditional retirement account to a Roth account. It does not add that money to your spending budget. The taxable portion can increase current income tax, and the household still needs cash for living expenses and the conversion tax.

Conversions can create future flexibility, but their value depends on when and how the money is used. A lower traditional-account balance can change future RMDs; the cost is paying conversion tax earlier. Nondeductible IRA contributions require special attention to basis and pro-rata treatment.

Fixed amounts versus bracket targets

A fixed strategy requests the same amount during the eligible years. A bracket target responds to the taxable income already occupying a selected bracket. The amount available can change when wages stop, Social Security begins, a pension starts, or deductions and filing status change.

As a simplified worksheet, if your chosen taxable-income ceiling were $90,000 and projected taxable income before conversion were $60,000, the apparent room would be $30,000. Those are hypothetical worksheet numbers, not published bracket limits. The actual conversion can affect other taxable income, and taxes funded from an IRA can reduce that room. Bracket room alone also does not account for Medicare or subsidy effects.

A reproducible example, not a forecast

Alex is a fictional single Washington resident, age 63 in 2026. The starting accounts are a $600,000 Traditional IRA, a $100,000 Roth IRA, and $100,000 in taxable cash, with no IRA basis or brokerage gains. Spending is $50,000 a year unless a comparison states otherwise. Social Security is entered as $2,500 a month at 67, with no subsequent COLA. The projection ends at 95 and uses age 80 as an intermediate comparison.

Investment returns, inflation, and fees are set to zero to make the tradeoffs easier to isolate. Healthcare is included in spending, with no separately modeled premiums or ACA credits. Federal taxes and RMDs are modeled; future-year tax assumptions can be projections. This deliberately simplified cash-only example is not a typical investment plan, a probability estimate, or a recommendation.

Results were calculated 2026-11-16 using retirement-model-2026.15. Dollar values are rounded, nominal, and before any tax on remaining accounts. Zero inflation makes them equal to first-year purchasing power in this example. Downloaded files preserve the selected inputs and reviewed data; calculation fixes can still change later results.

What happens with $20,000 or $40,000 a year?

The following choices hold withdrawal order at Taxable Accounts First and request fixed conversions from age 63 through 66, stopping before 67. These are fixed comparisons, not optimizer recommendations.

Calculated single-path comparison
ChoiceTax in 2026Portfolio at 80First spending shortfall
No Conversion$0$300,327Age 95
$20,000 Annual Conversion$390$292,748Age 95
$40,000 Annual Conversion$2,620$275,937Age 94

In this example, neither conversion schedule improves the age-80 portfolio balance. The $40,000 schedule also brings the first shortfall forward. With no growth or COLA and the stated spending and tax assumptions, paying tax earlier does not recover enough benefit later to overcome its cost.

This is why No Conversion belongs in the comparison. The result does not establish that conversions are generally harmful; different tax rates, returns, legacy goals, spending needs, and survivor circumstances can produce a different answer.

Download a fictional plan, then use Plan → Import Plan in the free or Plus planner. Importing replaces the current browser inputs; export your own plan first if you want to keep a separate file.

Download assumptions, calculation versions, and unrounded comparison results.

Use Plus to test the amount and the schedule

  1. Review your IRA basis, entered annual fixed conversions, conversion stop age, spending, and tax tables.
  2. Run No Conversion versus your fixed amounts as a baseline. This comparison is available in the free planner.
  3. In Plus, choose bracket-target optimization, an annual conversion limit, and the eligible age range. Select the available IRMAA guardrail that reflects what you want to test.
  4. Run the optimizer and inspect its annual schedule. A limit is not a promise that the engine will convert that full amount; account balances, eligibility, spending, and taxes can constrain it.
  5. Review near-term taxes, later RMDs, Medicare costs, spending coverage, and after-tax results. Test a candidate strategy against market uncertainty before applying it.
  6. Save a dated check-in, then confirm any recommendation you choose to apply. Revisit the schedule when balances, tax rules, or household circumstances change.

Look beyond the income-tax bracket

Medicare income-related adjustments generally use tax information from two years earlier. Conversion income can therefore affect premiums later. Marketplace coverage before Medicare may also make household income important. Our simplified example does not separately model either effect; enter them in your own plan rather than assuming they are zero.

Review the full tax consequences before executing a conversion. The planner estimates outcomes; it does not prepare a tax return or guarantee that an optimized schedule is appropriate for every account or household.

Official sources and related reading

A companion case study

How do different Roth conversion amounts change retirement results?

Follow a different fictional household through calculated alternatives and download the plans to reproduce the results.

Explore this with your own plan

Use the free planner to establish a baseline, then compare advanced strategies in Retirement Chartplotter Plus. Plus requires active access and runs calculations in your browser. Save account plans through My Plans and create a check-in before applying a recommendation.

Open the Planner Explore Retirement Chartplotter Plus